← Who is in the book Buy on Amazon

On the record · President of the United States

Theodore
Roosevelt

1858–1919

The President who called the operators and the miners to Washington in October 1902, without any legal power to settle the strike, and arranged the commission that ended it.

Theodore Roosevelt in pince-nez and a dark suit, head and shoulders, facing the camera.
Theodore Roosevelt in August 1902, seven weeks before the conference with the operators and the miners.Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division, LC-DIG-ppmsca-35706. No known restrictions on publication.

The chair

Theodore Roosevelt was born in New York City on October 27, 1858. He had been Assistant Secretary of the Navy, a colonel of volunteers in Cuba and governor of New York before he was elected vice president with William McKinley in 1900. McKinley was shot in Buffalo in September 1901, and Roosevelt took the oath there on September 14. He was forty-two.

On September 3, 1902, a trolley car hit the President's carriage near Pittsfield, Massachusetts. A Secret Service agent, William Craig, was killed, and Roosevelt was cut and bruised. Three weeks later, on a speaking tour, a swelling on his left leg had to be operated on at St. Vincent's Hospital in Indianapolis. He came back to Washington in a wheelchair, to the temporary White House on Jackson Place, and his surgeon operated again there on September 28.

The strike was in its fifth month and winter was coming. On October 3 Roosevelt brought both sides to Jackson Place: Mitchell and three district presidents of the United Mine Workers; Baer and the presidents of the other coal railroads; and John Markle for the independent operators. He received them in a wheelchair and a dressing gown, with his left leg on a cushion.

“There are three parties affected by the situation in the anthracite trade—the operators, the miners and the general public. I speak for neither the operators nor the miners, but for the general public.”Statement to the conference, October 3, 1902

Mitchell offered to send the men back to work if the President named a tribunal and both sides accepted its award. The operators refused and asked for troops. That day Roosevelt wrote to Senator Mark Hanna: “Well, I have tried and failed.”

The commission

He prepared to go further. In letters that month he described a plan to send in ten thousand regular troops, once the governor of Pennsylvania asked for help, and to have General John M. Schofield seize the mines and run them as receiver for the government. At the same time his Secretary of War, Elihu Root, went to J. P. Morgan. On October 11 Root spent most of a day aboard Morgan's yacht Corsair, and the two drafted an agreement for a commission to be appointed by the President.

The operators accepted on October 13, on condition that each seat go to a particular kind of man, one of them “a man of prominence eminent as a sociologist.” They would not have a union man. Late on the night of October 15, with two of Morgan's partners at Jackson Place, Roosevelt named E. E. Clark, head of the Order of Railway Conductors, to the sociologist's seat, “the President assuming that for the purposes of such a commission the term sociologist means a man who has thought and studied deeply on social questions.” Morgan and Baer agreed by telephone. Roosevelt also added a Catholic bishop, John L. Spalding. The statement was released at 2:20 on the morning of October 16.

Writing to Senator Henry Cabot Lodge the next day, Roosevelt said the operators “would rather have anarchy than tweedledum, but if I would use the word tweedledee they would hail it as meaning peace.” The miners' convention accepted the commission on October 21, and the men went back to work on October 23.

Five men in miners' caps and work clothes stand on a mine track; names are scratched on the negative above them.
Members of the commission in miners' clothes during their tour of the anthracite mines, November 1902. The names scratched on the negative read Parker, Moseley, Spalding, Gray and Wright.Bain News Service. Library of Congress, Prints and Photographs Division, LC-DIG-ggbain-08892. No known restrictions on publication.

Roosevelt won a full term in 1904. He died at Sagamore Hill, his home at Oyster Bay, New York, on January 6, 1919.

Mitchell·Baer·Darrow·Roosevelt·Mother Jones·Curran·Lloyd

Further study

  1. Theodore Roosevelt, An Autobiography (1913), chapter XIII, “Social and Industrial Justice.”
  2. Joseph Bucklin Bishop, Theodore Roosevelt and His Time, Shown in His Own Letters, vol. 1 (1920), chapter XIX.
  3. Elting E. Morison, ed., The Letters of Theodore Roosevelt, vol. 3 (1951).
  4. “Anthracite Coal Strike,” Theodore Roosevelt Center, Dickinson State University.
  5. Edmund Morris, Theodore Rex (Random House, 2001).
  6. Robert H. Wiebe, “The Anthracite Strike of 1902: A Record of Confusion,” Mississippi Valley Historical Review 48 (1961).