A companion to the novel in progress
Almost everyone in this book is a street. The men who argued over California in 1846 — and the men they arrested, outmaneuvered and displaced — are now directions you give a taxi driver. This is where they are, what they did to get there, and what is standing on the spot today.
The map
Fourteen names, one cityChoose a pin on either sheet.
Nine of these names are packed into forty square blocks downtown. The other five run from Eureka Valley out to the ocean. Start with 01 — he is the reason the republic lasted twenty-five days and not longer.
Why they are where they are
Three groups, laid downThe fourteen are not scattered at random. They fall into three groups, and the gaps between the groups say something the book keeps arriving at from other directions.
01–09 · the 1847 survey
Montgomery, Kearny, Stockton, Sutter and Fremont sit inside the survey Jasper O'Farrell ran in 1847 — months after the flag went up, while Kearny and Frémont were still arguing over which of them had been in charge. Larkin, Polk and Taylor come with the surveys pushing west just after.
Vallejo is the exception that explains the rule. He is the one Californio with a downtown street, and he is also the Californio the Americans found congenial — the man who had argued for annexation before the Bear Flaggers arrested him.
10–11 · the Californio streets
Castro and Noe are two miles southwest, in valleys subdivided well after 1847, and they carry the names of Californios who were losing the land the streets were cut through. Noé held Yerba Buena's civil authority as it stopped being a Mexican town; his Rancho San Miguel became a neighbourhood bearing his name and very little else of his.
12–14 · the afterthoughts
Sloat raised the first American flag in California and got a boulevard in the Parkside, laid out in the twentieth century, four miles from the grid his fellow officers share. Carson, the most famous name of all of them, got two blocks near Clarendon. Jessie Benton Frémont, who wrote the reports that made Frémont and Carson famous, got a narrow alley behind Market Street — and then, a century and a half later, the public square that alley gave its name to.
So the tidy version — winners downtown, losers outside — is not quite true. What is true is narrower and stranger: the streets named in 1847 are downtown, and everything named afterwards landed wherever the city happened to be expanding at the time. Rank on the map does not track rank in the story. It tracks the calendar.
This is the same pattern the bios keep running into: power decides whose paperwork survives. Here it decides street width — and Jessie Frémont, who did the writing, is the only one on this map commemorated at second hand: a square named after an alley named after her.
If you are actually in San Francisco
About a mile, mostly uphillSutter, Taylor, Larkin and Polk are all within another fifteen minutes west. Castro, Noe and Carson are a different trip entirely, which is the point of the section above.
The fourteen in full
Every pin on the map,John B. Montgomery
01 · Commander, USS Portsmouth
Came ashore at Yerba Buena on 9 July 1846 and raised the United States flag over the plaza, ending the California Republic at twenty-five days. He did it because Sloat had raised the flag at Monterey two days earlier, not because anyone in the town had asked.
What is there nowThe spine of the financial district. Portsmouth Square, two blocks uphill, is named for his ship.
Stephen Watts Kearny
02 · Brigadier General, Army of the West
Marched from Santa Fe with orders to take California and govern it, and arrived to find other men already governing it. He was mauled at San Pasqual on the way in. His fight with Frémont over who held command ended in a court-martial.
What is there nowRuns from Market past Portsmouth Square and on into North Beach.
Robert F. Stockton
03 · Commodore, United States Navy
Took over from Sloat, declared himself governor, commissioned Frémont, and conducted the conquest with a confidence his instructions did not support. Most of what Kearny later objected to, Stockton had already done.
What is there nowUnion Square to Chinatown, then under Nob Hill through the tunnel.
John A. Sutter
04 · Master of New Helvetia
A Swiss debtor who talked a Mexican governor into a private empire on the Sacramento and then held the interior for whoever looked likeliest to win. Vallejo was brought to his fort as a prisoner. Two years later a carpenter found gold in his millrace and ruined him.
What is there nowThe southern flank of Union Square.
Mariano Guadalupe Vallejo
05 · Californio general, Commandante at Sonoma
The most consequential Californio of the period, and the man the Bear Flaggers arrested at dawn on 14 June. He had been arguing for annexation to the United States before they came for him. He lost most of his land to American courts afterward.
What is there nowRuns east–west through North Beach, crossing Columbus.
John C. Frémont
06 · Brevet Captain, Topographical Engineers
Arrived surveying and stayed to command. He took a republic he had not declared and a war he had not been ordered to fight, was convicted of mutiny and pardoned, and ten years later ran for president. No one has ever produced his orders.
What is there nowSouth of Market, under the Transbay terminal.
Zachary Taylor
07 · Major General; later President
Fought the war two thousand miles from California and was carried into the White House by it, where he then had to decide what to do about the state it had produced — and whether it would be free.
What is there nowDown off Nob Hill and through the Tenderloin.
Thomas O. Larkin
08 · United States Consul at Monterey
Was quietly executing Polk's actual policy — persuade the Californios to ask to join — when the Bear Flag Revolt made persuasion impossible. He is the best argument in the book that it need not have gone this way.
What is there nowThe eastern edge of Civic Center.
James K. Polk
09 · President of the United States
Wanted California, got a war, and ran both from four months' distance by letter. Almost every decision in this story was made by someone guessing what he wanted.
What is there nowPolk Gulch, running the length of the city's middle.
José Castro
10 · Commandante General of Alta California
The Mexican military commander who ordered Frémont out of the province and was ignored, then was left to defend a territory his own government had not equipped him to hold. He withdrew to Mexico rather than surrender.
What is there nowThe heart of the Castro, two miles southwest of the 1847 grid.
Attribution contested
Some sources credit the general; others the Castro family of landholders. Needs checking before this goes out.
José de Jesús Noé
11 · Last Mexican alcalde of Yerba Buena
Held the town's civil authority as it stopped being a Mexican town — permits, disputes, property, the ordinary work that continues while governments exchange flags. He owned Rancho San Miguel, which is now a neighbourhood carrying his name and very little else of his.
What is there nowFrom the Castro down into Noe Valley.
Christopher "Kit" Carson
12 · Guide to the Frémont expeditions
Frémont's scout, and the one man here who became a legend in his own lifetime because somebody else wrote the reports. What he actually did on this expedition is harder reading than the legend.
What is there nowTwo blocks near Clarendon, the smallest street on this map.
Attribution unverified
The link to Kit Carson is plausible but I have not found it documented. Treat as unconfirmed.
John D. Sloat
13 · Commodore, Pacific Squadron
Raised the United States flag at Monterey on 7 July 1846, having finally satisfied himself that war with Mexico had been declared six weeks earlier and a thousand miles away. He had been cautious to the point of paralysis, and was relieved within three weeks. Stockton took the conquest from him, and most of the credit with it.
What is there nowA boulevard running to the ocean through the Parkside — four miles from the grid the other officers share, and laid out long after they were all dead.
No biography page yet
He appears in the twenty-five days on the main page but has no page of his own.
Jessie Benton Frémont
14 · Writer; daughter of Senator Thomas Hart Benton
She turned her husband's expedition notes into the published reports that made John C. Frémont a national figure and Kit Carson a legend. The prose that built both myths was substantially hers. It went out under his name, and she spent much of the rest of her life writing to keep the family solvent.
What is there nowA granite plaza in Yerba Buena, between the Contemporary Jewish Museum and St Patrick's Church, with a fountain and a good deal of foot traffic. It is the only entry on this map that is not a street.
Named at one remove, and unverified
The square takes its name from Jessie Street, the alley beside it; the alley's attribution to Jessie Benton Frémont is widely repeated but I have not found it documented. The Jessie Street in Mariposa, where the Frémonts held their gold-country estate, is hers.
Mason, Brannan, Guerrero, Sanchez and Bartlett are on the map too, and not yet on this page. The book is not a tour of street signs — but the coincidence is the point: a conquest carried out by a few dozen arguing men became the permanent grid of an American city.
Keep going
Three hand-drawn maps of California in 1846 — the road south to Monterey, the revolt's route from Yerba Buena to Sonoma, and the plan of the pueblo at dawn on the fourteenth of June — sit on the main page, along with the twenty-five days themselves.