Running through Breaker Boys is a series of dispatches from the coal country, published in 1902 over the initials E. M. Carroll: twelve cool, unsparing sketches of the breaker, the company store, the boys, the women, the private police. Who wrote them is one of the quiet turns of the novel.
The essays are set into the book between its chapters, in the voice of a period that produced a great deal of such writing. They are the book's second narrator — colder than the story around them, and harder to argue with.
Under the Breaker is fiction. The essays were written for this novel in a period voice; there was no E. M. Carroll, and no reader should go looking for them. For the history behind them, see The Breaker Boys: a history.
- I
The Breaker
The structure that governs every coal town
There is in the northern coal country no building so commanding as the breaker, and none so little understood by the people who warm themselves at its product. It stands at the head of the valley, eight stories of blackened timber, and the town does not so much lie beside it as fall away beneath it: the houses, the church, the company office arrange themselves below the breaker as a parish arranges itself below a steeple—save that the men who climb this tower do not go up to be the nearer to heaven, but to be fed into it.
- II
The Company Store
The dollar that never leaves the company's hand
- III
The Bobtail
Wherein the laborer is found to owe his employer
Of all the documents the coal region produces, the most instructive is the one the miners call a bobtail check — a check, that is, with nothing upon the end of it. It is the statement a man receives upon pay-day in the place of his wages, and it merits the attention of any citizen who supposes that to labor is, in this country, of necessity to be paid.
- IV
The Tongues of the Patch
Six-and-twenty nations at a single shaft
- V
Red Tops
The price in childhood at which the coal is bought
- VI
The Wash
The women, and their unending war with the dust
- VII
The Door
The youngest servants of the mine
- VIII
The Men With the Badges
A private army in the authority of the State
- IX
The Escort
Shenandoah, and the manufacture of a riot
- X
The Widow's Reckoning
What provision is made for the dead man's family
- XI
The Far End of the Coal
The poor are stationed at both ends of the seam
- XII
The Everlasting Cloud
A concluding word, to those who burn the coal
All twelve are in the novel
Thirty-one chapters, the epilogue, and every Under the Breaker sketch.