← Breaker Boys Buy on Amazon

Breaker Boys · Read the beginning

Prologue & Chapter One

The opening of Breaker Boys: A Novel of the Anthracite Wars, complete · about 3,700 words

Prologue

The Bellevue-Stratford Hotel, Philadelphia — Autumn 1918

In the autumn of 1918, John Mitchell was walking through the corridor of the Bellevue-Stratford Hotel in Philadelphia when the smell stopped him. It was nothing: a spent carbide lamp on a service cart outside a meeting room, the ghost of its extinguished flame still hanging in the air like the memory of something that had happened in another century. He stopped walking. The men with him continued another three steps before they noticed. They turned. He was standing with his hand on the wall, not because he needed support but because the wall was there, and the smell was doing something to him he could not account for and could not explain to men who had never sat alone in total darkness for ten hours with nothing for company but the sound of their own breathing and the distant, muffled intelligence of the earth.

“Mitchell?” Elgin said.

He looked up. “Forgive me,” he said. “I thought I smelled something.”

He had. He just could not say what.

Chapter One

The Boy in the Black Snow

Braidwood, Illinois — Spring, 1882

They say a coal mine will teach a boy everything he needs to know about this world, and most of what he needs to know about the next.

John Mitchell learned that lesson on his knees.

He was twelve years old the morning he first went to the coal, and he went as an orphan, though the law and the company ledger would not have named him such. His father was two years in the ground, kicked to death by a runaway team on a muddy February morning that John could still smell when the weather changed: horse sweat and cold mud and a sweetness underneath that he would only later understand was blood. His mother had been gone so long before that she had become less a memory than a rumor, a woman described to him only in his father’s rare, soft moments, when Robert Mitchell would press his thumb to the worn photograph and say nothing at all.

What John had instead of a mother was Agnes.

Agnes Mitchell, née Hogarth, was his stepmother of three years and she was a woman constructed entirely of grievance. She was not a monster in the way the stories prefer. She did not beat them or lock them in cellars. Her cruelties were smaller and more durable than that. She withheld warmth the way a mine operator withholds wages: methodically, with justification, always in her own interest. She fed the children because it would have been noticed if she had not. She kept the house because it was hers now. There was a coldness to her stewardship that settled into the bones and stayed there, like the damp of a poorly ventilated shaft.

When Robert Mitchell died, Agnes looked at John across the kitchen table for a long time. Then she said, simply, “You’ll need to find work.”

He was ten years old. He found work at twelve.

* * *

The Chicago, Wilmington, and Vermillion Coal Company kept the breaker boys in a long, low building that crouched at the foot of the headframe like something ashamed of itself. The structure was wood, once painted red, though the coal dust had long since eaten the color down to a uniform gray that matched the February sky and the faces of the men trudging toward the cage at dawn. Inside, the noise was biblical. The coal screamed down through iron chutes, a sound like the end of a conversation between two mountains, endless and indifferent and without appeal.

The foreman’s name was Dawes. He was no crueler than the system required him to be, and no kinder than it allowed. He put John on a bench in the middle row, between a boy of fourteen named Corcoran whose left hand was missing two fingers, and a child so young and small that John initially mistook him for a bundle of rags someone had forgotten.

“Mind the chute,” Corcoran said, by way of introduction. “She throws slate wide when she’s moving fast.”

John nodded. He did not yet know what slate was, in the way that a man knows what salt is, by tasting it. He would learn.

The work was this: the coal came down the chutes in a rushing black river, and the boys picked through it with their bare hands, pulling out the grey shards of slate and rock that were worthless, leaving only the coal — though in Braidwood that coal was bituminous, softer, with none of the blue-flame dignity of the hard coal men would one day strike for. Their fingers had to be quick and sure. The edges of the slate were as sharp as broken crockery. By the end of his first hour, John’s hands were bleeding in four places. By the end of the week, he had stopped noticing.

The dust was the thing that surprised him most. He had expected the dark. He had not expected the way the dust got inside of everything: his lungs, his eyes, the food he ate at midday, the very thoughts in his head. It fell through the light like black snow that never settled, so that you breathed it in and breathed it in and could never be free of it. The older boys had a permanent cough that marked them the way a brand marks a calf. John would lie awake at night in the room he shared with his two brothers and listen to that cough moving through the houses of the patch like a ghost that called on everyone.

The fear had a texture by then. Rough and familiar, like the handle of a coal pick. He carried it with him the way he carried his lunch pail. He did not let it show. A boy who cried in the breaker was a boy who went home with less.

* * *

Corcoran had lost his fingers in April of the previous year.

He told John about it on the third day, without particular drama, the way you might describe a change in the weather.

“She came down fast and I was slow,” he said, holding up the abbreviated hand. The stumps were smooth now, healed to a pale pink that looked oddly young against the coal-stained rest of him. “Dawes gave me a week off. Docked from wages.”

“Did it hurt?” John asked.

Corcoran considered. “Still does,” he said. “Some mornings.”

The company’s position on such matters was clearly stated in no document John had ever been given to read, because John had been given no documents at all. But it was legible in everything around him: in the way Dawes moved past an injured boy without stopping, in the way the company doctor arrived three days after an accident rather than one, in the way the men spoke about death the way other men spoke about weather, as a force beyond argument, to be endured.

* * *

The small boy’s name was Tomasz, though the foreman called him Tom and the other boys called him nothing at all, because he was too young to have earned a name from them and too quiet to insist on one. He could not have been more than nine. He sat at the low end of the row, where the coal ran fastest, because the low end was where the smallest hands went, and he worked with a concentration John recognized, because it was the concentration of a boy who has understood that the work is the only thing standing between him and being sent home with less.

It happened on a morning in late August, in the second hour, when the chutes were running full and the noise was at its worst.

John did not see the beginning of it. No one ever saw the beginning of it; that was the nature of the breaker, which arranged its accidents in the one place a boy’s eyes were already fixed and still contrived to make them happen too fast to follow. He saw the end. He saw the boy go forward into the coal as though he had decided to dive into it, and he saw the older boys lunge and miss, and he heard, under the grinding of the chutes, a sound that was not part of the machine and that the machine did not pause to acknowledge.

The coal kept coming. That was the part John would carry. Not the boy — the boy was gone almost before the mind could frame the fact of him —but the coal, which continued down the chute in its black indifferent river, burying what it had done, because there was no one at the engine house who had been told to stop it and no reason in the company’s arithmetic to tell them.

Dawes came. The chutes were stopped, eventually, by a man who had to walk the length of the breaker to reach the lever. The boy was brought out. John did not look closely and was not made to. The others stood in the sudden, enormous silence of the halted machine and listened to a quiet they had not heard during working hours in all the months John had been there, and it was worse than the noise, because the noise at least had no opinion.

They were picking again within the hour. The chutes ran. The coal came down. A space had opened at the low end of the row where the fastest coal ran, and by the afternoon a new boy had been put into it, smaller even than the last, and the work closed over the morning the way the river of coal had closed over the boy, completely and without a mark.

John went home that evening and did not eat. He lay in the dark beside Tommie and listened to the cough moving through the patch, and he understood something he would spend the rest of his life finding words adequate to. It was not that the company was cruel. Cruelty he could have hated cleanly. It was that the company did not stop the coal. The coal was money and the money did not stop, and a boy who went into the chute was a brief interruption in an accounting that resumed before he had finished dying. There was no one to hate. There was only the arrangement. And an arrangement, he saw — lying there at twelve with his bleeding hands curled against his chest — could not be wept at or reasoned with or forgiven. It could only be opposed by another arrangement, built to be as patient as itself.

He thought about his father. Robert Mitchell had worked a mine not so different from this one. Had breathed the same dust and carried the same fear. Had died not underground but above it: a mercy of geography that his son, even at twelve, recognized as random and unearned, the kind of accident a man had no right to count on twice.

* * *

There was a woman who came sometimes to the edge of the patch.

She was from neither the company nor the church, which meant she was from no institution the miners trusted, and so they watched her with the wariness of men disappointed by every institution in sequence. She was no longer young; her hair was going gray at the temples. She dressed plainly, without the fuss of the town women who toured the operations to satisfy some appetite for the picturesque. She dressed like someone who intended to stay.

John first noticed her in June, standing at the gate of the yard where the boys were let out at the end of the shift, watching them file past with an expression he could not name. She had the face of a person angry on his behalf, who had decided to do something about it and had not yet finished deciding what.

One evening she was there when John came out alone — Corcoran had gone ahead, the small boy had family waiting — and she looked at him directly, which adults rarely did.

“How old are you?” she said.

“Fourteen,” he said, which was what you said.

She looked at him for a long moment. Her eyes were the color of the river in November. “No,” she said, pleasantly. “You’re not.”

He said nothing. He had already learned that silence was safer than agreement, and far safer than contradiction.

“What’s your name?”

“Mitchell. John Mitchell.”

She nodded slowly, as if she were filing this away. “Your father work here?”

“He did. He’s dead.”

Something moved across her face. Something like recognition. As if she had been collecting dead fathers for some purpose and he had just added one to the ledger.

“Who do you live with?”

“My stepmother. And my brothers.”

“She send you here?”

He thought of Agnes at the kitchen table. Of the way she looked at him as if he were a problem that had been assigned to her without her consent.

“Yes.”

The woman nodded again. She reached into the canvas bag she was carrying and took out a bread roll, the good kind, yeasty and still warm from somewhere. She held it out.

John looked at it. His hands were filthy. His hands were always filthy.

“Go on,” she said. “I didn’t bake it for myself.”

He took it. He ate it standing there in the yard, and she watched him with that same un-pitying attention, as if she were studying him for some examination that had not yet been announced.

“You’re going to be important someday,” she said, when he had finished. “You’ve got the look of a man who pays attention.”

He didn’t know what to say to that. He was twelve years old and his hands were bleeding and he smelled of coal dust and he had a stepmother at home who regarded him as a necessary inconvenience. The idea that any of this was preparation for something struck him as the kind of thing adults said to children to make them feel better, which was to say a lie with good intentions.

“Yes, ma’am.”

She smiled. It was a fierce smile, not a comfortable one. “Don’t ‘yes ma’am’ me. I’m not your school-teacher. I’m telling you something true.” She picked up her bag. “Pay attention to everything, boy. The men who run this world are counting on you not to.”

She walked away then, through the gate and down the road toward town, without looking back.

John ate the rest of the bread.

* * *

On the last Saturday of each month the men were paid, and John learned the shape of a payday before he learned the shape of much else, because the payday was where the arithmetic of the patch became visible for an afternoon before going back into hiding.

He went with the men to the company office because Agnes sent him to collect what was owed for his own work. He stood in the line in the cold and watched the clerk work down the ledger with a pen, and he watched the faces of the men as they reached the window, and he saw on a good many of them an expression he came to know: the particular stillness of a man being told, in figures, that a month of his life had come to nothing.

They called it a bobtail check. A man would work the month and present himself at the window, and the clerk would read out the account — so much earned, so much for rent, so much for powder and oil and the sharpening of tools, so much at the store for flour and meat and the boots the children had needed — and at the bottom of the column there would be a figure. Sometimes the figure was small. Sometimes it was nothing. Sometimes it was less than nothing, and the man would be handed not money but a slip of paper showing what he now owed for the privilege of having worked.

John watched a man named Pawlak — a Pole, big through the shoulders, who John had seen lift things other men would not attempt — receive such a slip and stand looking at it. Pawlak could not read the figures and did not need to; the clerk’s face read them for him. He said something in Polish that John did not understand and that needed no understanding, and the clerk said, in English, not unkindly, that he was sorry, and that there was always next month, and the line moved Pawlak gently along by the pressure of the men behind him who also wished to know what their month had come to.

It was done in a fair hand. That was the thing John kept returning to, then and for years after. No one cheated. The figures were honest. The rent was the rent and the flour was the flour, each set down at a price the company had fixed and the man had no power to dispute, and the sum of these honest figures was a man who could not leave — because to leave he would have to clear the debt, and to clear the debt he would have to work, and to work he would have to stay, and to stay was to acquire more debt. It was not a trap the way a snare is a trap. It was a trap the way a circle is a trap: by having no end.

He carried his own few coins home to Agnes, who counted them without comment, and he understood that the coins were not the point. The point was the circle. The point was that the company did not need to chain a man to the patch when it could arrange the figures so that the man chained himself, freely, every month, and called it earning a living.

* * *

Summer became autumn. Autumn became the particular grey of an Illinois winter, which is a grey without drama or beauty, only duration.

John Mitchell learned the breaker. He learned its rhythms the way you learn a body of water: where it was calm, where it moved fast, where it would kill you if you stopped paying attention. He learned which foremen could be reasoned with and which could not, which older boys would share food and which would take yours. He learned to cough without showing it, to bleed without stopping, to be afraid without appearing to be.

Every evening, walking home through the patch in the early dark, he passed the houses of the men with their families inside, their lights on, the occasional child’s voice carrying out through a thin wall, and he catalogued them. The weight of what he saw. The arithmetic of exhaustion on a grown man’s face. The way the company owned the house and the house owned the man and the man owned nothing at all, not even the hours of his life, which he sold at the gate each morning for a wage that the company store would patiently retrieve before the month was out.

He paid attention to everything.

Under the Breaker

Sketches from the Anthracite Country

The Breaker

Concerning the structure that governs every coal town, and what it has made of the valley and the men.

Wilkes-Barre — May 1902

By E. M. Carroll

There is in the northern coal country no building so commanding as the breaker, and none so little understood by the people who warm themselves at its product. It stands at the head of the valley, eight stories of blackened timber, and the town does not so much lie beside it as fall away beneath it: the houses, the church, the company office arrange themselves below the breaker as a parish arranges itself below a steeple—save that the men who climb this tower do not go up to be the nearer to heaven, but to be fed into it. Whoever would understand the anthracite region, its labor and its poverty and its strikes, must begin with the breaker, for the breaker has arranged everything else.

Considered as an institution, the breaker is the point at which the coal is broken and sorted, and at which the men are broken and sorted along with it. It runs the daylight hours without ceasing, and the sound it makes —a continuous grinding roar, beneath which lies the finer hiss of the dust —the inhabitants no longer hear, as a man beside a cataract ceases to hear the water. The dust is the breaker’s exhalation. It settles upon the window-sills, the linen on the line, the food upon the table, and the lungs of the children, and it confers upon the whole settlement a single color, which is the color of a thing that has been burned and has not finished burning.

Beside the breaker stands its companion and its monument, the culm bank: an artificial mountain reared out of all that the coal was not worth— the slate, the rock, the small refuse coal that no market will receive—and rising a little with every working day. The visitor who knew this valley a generation since would not now know it. The timber is gone, cut away for props and shoring; the streams that are said once to have held trout run the color of rust, charged with the iron water that drains from the abandoned workings, and harbor nothing that lives; the green country has become the gray of an old photograph. All of this the breaker has accomplished. It has not, as the sentimental would have it, ruined the valley; it has used it—used the hills, the water, the timber, and the men, in the one comprehensive operation of which it is the visible sign. With this fact the inquiry must begin, for every other fact in the region descends from it.

Read the rest

Thirty-one chapters, the epilogue, and all twelve Under the Breaker sketches.

Kindle · $7.99 Paperback · $22.00

The research notes

One email when the next novel is out, and occasional notes from the research. Nothing else, and you can leave at any time.

Hear about the next book

About the book, the history and the people in it →